Oracle v Google Trial Could Start April
Oracle v Google Trial Could Start April
Written by Sue Gee   
Friday, 10 February 2012

It now seems that the Oracle-Google lawsuit over Android patents and copyright issues could go ahead as soon as April 2012, thanks to some unexpected maneuvering on the part of  Oracle.

In our last installment of the ongoing saga of this face-off between two Goliaths we were of the opinion that the trial could easily slip onto 2013. However, within a couple of days Oracle offered a surprise concession that had the effect of moving the schedule forward.

Oracle is the party in this lawsuit wanting a trial as quickly as possible and to try to achieve this it offered to stay its patent claims, focusing instead just on the copyright infringement and also waive its right to submitting a third damages report - the judge in the case having already dismissed too damages claims as being far too extravagant.

Although Judge William Alsup rejected Oracle's proposals of splitting the patent and copyright issues as "a piecemeal approach" he did respond positively by clearing the way for a trial in mid-April. Oracle is also going to present a third damages claim, having agreed to pick up the costs arising from it.

One setback for Oracle comes from new claim constructions of two of the six patents that Oracle is asserting against Google. In one case Google  has persuaded the judge to adopt a broad interpretation of the meaning of the term "computer-readable medium" and in the other "at runtime" is to be given a narrow interpretation, which again will favor Google's case.

Meanwhile Google has suffered a setback in that it has failed for the seventh time to have the Lindholm e-mail, a potential damning piece of evidence in terms of copyright infringement, to be excluded from evidence.

As Florian Mueller's post points out:

If Oracle manages to inject the Lindholm email into the early stage of the trial, the jury will basically know that Google itself knows there's some infringement somewhere.



More Information

FOSS Patents

Judge refuses to separate patent claims from Oracle-Google case but trial could start in mid-April

Failed attempt #7: Federal Circuit denies Google petition to exclude Lindholm email


Related Articles

Oracle v Google faces further delays




blog comments powered by Disqus


To be informed about new articles on I Programmer, subscribe to the RSS feed, follow us on Google+, Twitter, Linkedin or Facebook or sign up for our weekly newsletter.


Microsoft Build Clashes With Google I/O

The respective Microsoft and Google Developer conferences are the year's highlights for many - and many of us have allegiances to both. This year the dates of the two events coincide. Was it deliberat [ ... ]

Open Media Alliance AV1 Is Better Than JPEG

The Alliance for Open Media's work on an alternative video codec is making progress with tests in a trial version of Firefox showing that the Alliance's AV1 video compression technology produces video [ ... ]

More News

Last Updated ( Wednesday, 22 February 2012 )

RSS feed of news items only
I Programmer News
Copyright © 2018 All Rights Reserved.
Joomla! is Free Software released under the GNU/GPL License.