Schmidt and Schwartz Defend Google's Use Of Java APIs
Written by Sue Gee   
Thursday, 12 May 2016

At the start of the second Oracle v Google trial, Alphabet CEO Eric Schmidt told the court that in creating Android Google used only what it thought was freely available, including the Java language and its APIs.

The opening shot in this rematch to determine whether Google's use of the Java APIs in its Android operating system can be considered fair use was made by Oracle lawyer Peter Bicks. He told the jury:

"Three billion mobile phones have been activated with Oracle's property on them... There are 100,000 Android phones being activated each hour... $42 billion in revenue through all of those activations. Each with our client's property in them. Valuable computer code."

Bicks went on to make a pre-emptive strike on Google's fair use defence, showing a software map to demonstrate the importance of the API code and its extent. Claiming that Google "took the heart of these packages he told the jury:

"You may hear today that 11,000 lines is not a lot 'We left a lot behind,' is what you'll hear. 'We took your property, but we didn't take all of it.' 11,000 lines is a lot of computer code."

While a main plank of Bick's case is that Google used the Java APIs without permission, part of Eric Schmit's defence rests on the fact that both the Java language and its APIs were freely available and that Sun didn't object to the way it was used.


Asked by Google's own attorney Robert Van Nest as to the basis of his belief that Google didn't need  a license to use 37 Java application programming interfaces for which Oracle now owns the copyright, Schmidt replied:

 “Forty years of experience”

indicating that it was common belief in the industry that APIs can be used without a license.

This line of the argument was confirmed by Jonathan Schwartz, the former CEO of Sun, the company that created Java before it was acquired by Oracle. Schwartz maintained that Java was free because Sun was attempting to promote it among young and future developers, primarily those who were still attending schools and colleges. He referred to the GNU Classpath project, an open source Java-powered creation that stemmed from this policy and which Sun was subsequently forced to compete with stating that the GNU Classpath developers did not take any kind of license for using Java APIs and his former company obviously did not take them to court over that despite directly competing with them.  



$5 million For Open Source Software Projects for Science

The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative has announced funding for over forty open source tools that are essential to biomedical research. There will be two more opportunities for OSS projects to requ [ ... ]

New Database For Data Scientists

A new database designed to help data science teams make faster discoveries by giving them a more powerful way to store, update, analyze, and share large sets of diverse data has been released.

More News






or email your comment to:

Last Updated ( Thursday, 12 May 2016 )