Churchill Navigation is challenging developers to beat its own solution to an interesting problem. There's a first prize of $5K plus two runner-up awards of $2000 and $500.


To quote from the challenge web page:

In a nutshell: We give you a bunch of ranked 2D points, then ask you to find the most important ones inside some randomly generated rectangles. Easy, right?


To take part in the contest you need to download a zip file that contains the precise problem definition, a testing framework that can load one of more dlls to evaluate their performance and compare their results and a reference solution used to test for correctness.

The important criteria here is speed - the DLL that provides the correct answer and fastest will be the winner.

The deadline for the contest is 5pm MST on February 10, 2015 and the leaderboard reveals that currently one team has a faster solution than the in-house team.




Churchill Navigation is a pioneer of Augmented Reality Mapping and has a Mission Management Mapping System that is used by law enforcement agencies. The challenge it has set isn't intended to be directly product related. According to Andras Balogh, who posted news of the competition to Reddit, the problem was originally used for interviewing purposes the idea of turning it into an open-to-all contest was as:

 a fun way to get engaged with the programmer community, and meet some smart engineers

Judging from some of the comments on Reddit, and from the water-cooler discussion of in the I Programmer office the problem is one that devs do find interesting, with several alternative approaches being suggested. Most involve presorting the data in some way either via a direct sort or using a data structure like a quadtree (see Quadtrees and Octrees). One or two people mentioned geographic hashing and a few hybrid schemes have been suggested.  




As Andras says:

it's fun to see all the different ways people solve the same problem!

He also undertakes to share the in-house team's solution and  along with those of the winning team(s) and says that runtimes will be published once the contest is over.

More Information

Churchill Navigation Programming Challenge

Discussion on Reddit

Related Articles

Algorithm Challenge To Aid Environmental Protection

Quadtrees and Octrees       


To be informed about new articles on I Programmer, install the I Programmer Toolbar, subscribe to the RSS feed, follow us on, Twitter, FacebookGoogle+ or Linkedin,  or sign up for our weekly newsletter.



Java 10 Improves Garbage Collection
19 Apr 2018 16:19 - Alex Denham

Java 10, a feature release of Java SE, has improved its garbage collection and compilation, and has also extended the Class-Data Sharing feature to improve startup and footprint. 

Arkansas Offers Incentives For AP Computer Science
22 Oct 2017 00:00 - Sue Gee

The US state of Arkansas is planning to give cash rewards of up to $1000 to high school students who gain top grades in Computer Science exams.

Other Articles






or email your comment to: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.